Blogs

Depression is more than just feeling sad; it is a serious medical condition that can impact every aspect of your life, including your ability to work. If you are struggling with severe depression, you may be entitled to disability benefits to provide financial support while you focus on your health. Understanding how to access these benefits can feel overwhelming, but this guide is here to help.

We will walk you through the key aspects of applying for disability benefits for depression in 2025. You will learn about eligibility, the application process, and how to handle common challenges. With the right information, you can navigate this process with confidence.

Understanding Disability Benefits for Depression

When depression makes it impossible to maintain employment, disability benefits can serve as a vital financial lifeline. In Canada, these benefits typically come from two main sources: group insurance policies provided by an employer and government programs like the Canada Pension Plan (CPP) Disability benefit.

Depression is considered an “invisible illness,” meaning it doesn’t have the obvious physical signs of other disabilities. This can sometimes make claims more complex. However, insurance companies and government bodies recognize severe, treatment-resistant depression as a legitimate basis for a disability claim. The key is to demonstrate, with strong medical evidence, that your condition prevents you from performing the essential duties of your occupation.

Eligibility Criteria for Mental Health Disability Claims in 2025

To qualify for disability benefits for depression, you must meet specific criteria. While the details can vary between insurance policies, the core requirements are generally consistent.

Defining “Total Disability”

The most critical part of your claim is proving you meet your policy’s definition of “total disability.” Most policies have a two-part definition:

1. Own Occupation: For the first 24 months, you typically must prove that your depression prevents you from performing the essential tasks of your current
2. Any Occupation: After 24 months, the definition often shifts. You must then prove that your condition prevents you from performing any job for which you are reasonably suited by education, training, or experience.

Providing Sufficient Medical Evidence

Strong medical documentation is the foundation of a successful claim. Your application must be supported by evidence that clearly outlines your diagnosis, symptoms, and functional limitations. This includes:

• A confirmed diagnosis of a recognized depressive disorder (e.g., Major Depressive Disorder, Persistent Depressive Disorder) from a qualified medical professional, such as a family doctor, psychiatrist, or psychologist.
• Detailed treatment records, showing you are actively seeking and following medical advice. This can include regular appointments, medication history, and therapy sessions (like CBT or psychotherapy).
• Reports from medical specialists, particularly a psychiatrist. An opinion from a specialist carries significant weight in mental health disability claims.
• A written statement from your doctor explaining how your symptoms (e.g., fatigue, poor concentration, memory loss, lack of motivation) directly impact your ability to perform your job duties.

The Application Process: A Step-by-Step Guide

Applying for disability benefits requires careful attention to detail. Following a structured approach can help ensure your application is complete and compelling.

1. Review Your Insurance Policy

Before you begin, get a copy of your group benefits booklet or individual disability policy. Read the section on long-term disability (LTD) benefits carefully. Pay close attention to the definition of “total disability,” the waiting period (also known as the elimination period), and any exclusions or limitations.

2. Gather Your Forms

The application package usually consists of three parts:

• Plan Member’s Statement: You complete this form, providing information about your job, your medical condition, and how it affects your ability to work.
• Employer’s Statement: Your employer completes this form, detailing your job duties, salary, and work history.
• Attending Physician’s Statement (APS): Your primary treating doctor (usually your family doctor or psychiatrist) completes this form. It is one of the most important documents in your application.

3. Work with Your Doctor

Schedule a dedicated appointment with your doctor to discuss the Attending Physician’s Statement. Do not just drop off the form. Explain the importance of the document and provide your doctor with a detailed description of your job duties. This helps them connect your symptoms directly to your inability to work. Ensure they provide specific, objective examples of your limitations rather than vague statements.

4. Submit the Complete Application

Once all forms are filled out, make copies for your records and submit the entire package to the insurance company. Be sure to submit it before any deadlines specified in your policy.

Common Challenges and How to Overcome Them

Many initial applications for mental health disability claims are denied. Being aware of common pitfalls can help you prepare a stronger case from the start.

Challenge: Insufficient Medical Evidence

A denial letter often states there is “insufficient objective evidence” of disability. For depression, this means the insurer feels your medical file doesn’t adequately prove your functional limitations.

• Solution: Be proactive. Regularly see your doctor and any specialists. A consistent record of treatment and documented symptoms is crucial. Consider undergoing a neuropsychological evaluation, which can provide objective data on how depression affects your cognitive abilities like memory, concentration, and executive functioning.

Challenge: The Insurer’s Medical Consultants

Insurance companies employ their own doctors and medical consultants who may review your file and conclude you are capable of working. These consultants have never met you and base their opinion solely on the documents provided.

• Solution: Your best defence is a robust medical file from your own treating specialists. A detailed, well-reasoned report from your psychiatrist who sees you regularly will often hold more weight than the opinion of an insurer’s paper-based reviewer.

Challenge: Surveillance

In some cases, insurers may hire private investigators to conduct surveillance. They might film you running errands or participating in social activities to argue that you are more functional than you claim.

• Solution: Be honest and consistent. Your medical records, your application, and your daily activities should all tell the same story. If you report being unable to concentrate for more than 15 minutes, but are seen reading a book in a park for an hour, it could be used against you. Follow your doctor’s recommendations for activity, and be truthful about your good days and bad days.

Maximizing Your Chances of Approval

A well-prepared application is your best tool for success.

• Be Specific and Detailed: When describing your symptoms, explain how they prevent you from working. Instead of saying “I have poor concentration,” say “My inability to concentrate prevents me from reading and responding to work emails, which makes up 50% of my job.”
• Demonstrate Credibility: Follow your doctor’s treatment plan diligently. If a specific medication or therapy is recommended, you should try it (unless you have a valid medical reason not to). This shows the insurer you are doing everything possible to get better.
• Keep a Journal: Documenting your daily symptoms, energy levels, and limitations can provide valuable information for you and your doctor. It helps create a more complete picture of your condition over time.

How Kotak Law Can Help

Navigating a disability claim for depression can be an exhausting battle, especially when you are already struggling with your health. This is where Kotak Law can make a significant difference. Our experienced disability lawyers focus exclusively on this area of law.

If your claim has been denied or terminated, we can help. We will:

• Review Your Denial Letter: We analyze the insurer’s reasons for denial and identify weaknesses in their position.
• Handle All Communications: We take over all correspondence with the insurance company, so you can focus on your recovery.
• Gather Stronger Evidence: We work with you and your doctors to gather the necessary medical documentation to build a powerful case.
• Fight for Your Rights: We are prepared to negotiate a fair settlement or, if necessary, take your case to court to secure the benefits you deserve.

You do not have to face the insurance company alone. Contact Kotak Law today for a free consultation to learn how we can support you in your fight for disability benefits for depression.

 

Disclaimer: This blog post is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. You should consult with a lawyer for advice regarding your individual situation.